Making the UK greener, one house at a time
Mentioned in
The Guardian logoHarvard University logoIndependent logoSPACE.com logoForbes logo
Last updated: 25 October 2024

Are LED Lights Bad For The Environment?

Switch to LED lighting for a brighter, more sustainable future. These energy-efficient bulbs reduce your carbon footprint and help conserve resources
  • LED lights save energy and last 20 times longer than traditional bulbs, but they can cause light pollution and harm wildlife.
  • Producing and disposing of LED lights can be bad for the environment, as they contain plastics and leads that don't break down easily.
  • To make LED lights better for the environment, we need to improve how they are produced and recycled.

LED lighting is one of the most eco-friendly choices for energy efficiency, and it has boosted impressive energy savings over traditional lights. Due to their efficiency,  most households, workplaces, and outdoor spaces have adopted them. However, this has led to unexpected consequences, such as an increase in the light population.

According to some studies, LEDs emit more blue lights, which are seen in the atmosphere, contributing to sky glow and potentially covering the stars. 

This influence of blue light has led to light pollution, which affects human health, animals and plant growth.

Consequently, we need to have more strategic, innovative, and regulatory LED production in place. These approaches would pave the way for solutions that mitigate the environmental effects and will go a long way in protecting the environment. 

LED Energy Efficiency and Longevity

LED lights already use 80% less energy than traditional bulbs. But we can take this step further by pairing them with solar panels, which can make them even greener. This combination will also cut electricity cut and lower carbon emissions from power plants.

Should businesses and cities worldwide embrace LEDs, carbon reduction could potentially drop by over 553 million metric tons annually.

In addition to being efficient with power, LED lights offer a longer lifespan. A typical LED bulb can last for approximately 25,000 to 50,000 hours or more. That is a substantial jump compared to an incandescent bulb's lifespan of about 1,000 hours. This means LEDs can last for 20 times longer by a significant margin.

However, switching entirely would result in global electricity savings of an estimated 1,132 TWh. The equivalent annual consumption of nearly half a million households leads to monetary savings of £148 billion every year on electrical costs.

Besides, this longer lifespan means fewer bulbs reaching landfills. This equates not only to fewer resources spent in production and disposal but also to enhanced energy conservation that further reduces greenhouse gas emissions.

  1. Annual Impact: LED lighting is making waves in reducing our global carbon footprint. It shows that LED adoption has doubled since 2017, and efficiency has improved. The current impact ranges between 1,000 to 1,400 million tons of CO2 emissions eliminated annually. This is equivalent to shutting down approximately 850 - 1,200 coal-fired power plants. Moreover, switching to LEDs could prevent the construction of 1,250 power stations worldwide and reduce our energy consumption for lighting from 12% to 8% of global electricity.
  2. Daily Impact: Let's break it down to a daily level. Every single day, LED lights are working hard to reduce our environmental impact. If we divide the annual CO2 reduction by 365 days, we're looking at roughly 1.56 million tons of CO2 saved per day thanks to LEDs. That's like taking over 339,000 cars off the road every single day! Furthermore, LED street lights can significantly reduce municipal electricity costs, with potential savings of 20-40% on public lighting bills.
  3. Impact Per Usage: Now, let's zoom in even further. How much difference can one LED bulb make? A lot, as it turns out. A single incandescent bulb contributes about 4,500 lbs (2,041 kg) of CO2 annually, while an LED bulb only adds 451 lbs (204.5 kg). That's a 90% reduction from just one bulb! The impact of every household replacing bulbs with an LED will save over £250 on energy bills. 

Countries and Industries Leading the LEDS Adoption

While LED adoption is a global trend, some countries and industries are leading the pack:

  1. China: As the world's largest LED producer and consumer, China's push for LED adoption is significantly influencing global trends
  2. United States: The US Department of Energy's initiatives, like the Better Buildings Challenge, have been crucial in promoting LED adoption. This country is dominating the global LED lighting market with approximately 30%
  3. European Union: With stringent energy efficiency regulations, the EU is driving rapid LED adoption. The European LED market is expected to grow from £8.51 billion in 2024 to £11.84 billion by 2030.
  4. Japan: The Japanese market is projected to grow at an impressive CAGR of 12.2% from 2023 to 2030, thanks to innovative LED solutions from local companies.
  5. Industrial Sector: This sector holds enormous potential. A typical refinery switching to LEDs could reduce CO2 emissions by 1,530 metric tons annually - equivalent to planting 1,801 acres of trees.

Environmental Impact of LEDs

While LED lights have gained popularity due to their energy efficiency and longevity, we need to consider some environmental concerns associated with their use. These issues range from the blue light effect, light pollution, potential wildlife disruption and electronic waste problems.

LED streetlights have been linked to increased light pollution in many areas, especially in Europe. Their brightness and the way they scatter light can create a "sky glow" effect, making it harder to see stars at night. 

Countries such as the UK, Ireland and France primarily utilise LED lights for street lighting, making them the countries most influenced by the effects of LED lighting, as researchers discovered. Italy, Romania, Ireland, and Spain are also in the mix conversion of street lighting to white LEDs.

This not only affects our ability to enjoy the night sky but can also impact ecosystems that rely on natural light cycles.

AspectLEDIncandescentCFL
Energy Efficiency (lumens/watt)80-10015-2060-70
Lifespan (hours)25,000-50,0001,000-2,0008,000-10,000
Blue Light EmissionHighLowMedium
Mercury ContentNoneNoneContains mercury
Heat GenerationLowHighMedium

Light Pollution and Wildlife Disruption

The use of LED lighting, specifically in outdoor environments with high levels of blue light, is leading to considerable light pollution. This goes beyond just the inability to see stars during the night. It poses a significant issue for animals as well.

For humans, excessive blue light exposure during nighttime can disturb the sleep patterns of individuals. Our bodies naturally start to relax in darkness, but intense LED lights can deceive our brains into believing it's still daytime. This may result in difficulties with sleeping and various other health problems.

Many nocturnal animals are negatively impacted by too much artificial light because they rely on darkness for activities like navigation, hunting, and protection.

Meanwhile, birds and insects are drawn to artificial light, which can result in more collisions with buildings and other structures.

Artificial lighting can also disturb plants' natural growth cycles and seasonal variations.

Manufacturing and Disposal Challenges

While LEDs are more energy-efficient during use, their production process is only sometimes environmentally friendly. Manufacturing LEDs requires rare earth elements and other materials that can be harmful to extract and process. 

This raises questions about the overall environmental impact of LED production. The extraction of these materials often involves energy-intensive mining and chemical processes, potentially causing soil and water waste and pollution.

LED bulb disposal presents a challenging issue, adding to e-waste. Although they lack mercury found in some bulbs, they have electronic components and traces of materials that can harm the environment if discarded incorrectly. 

Due to Improper disposal, these parts can end up in landfills. This risks toxic leakage that can contaminate soil and water sources due to metals like lead, cadmium, and arsenic present in LEDs.

Solving this involves enhancing waste solutions and recycling efforts for LED lights. Yet, current recycling measures still need to be improved across regions. Initiatives like take-back systems and designing with lifecycle considerations are required improvements.

The Rebound Effect

Sometimes, efficiency can have unexpected negative consequences. With the decreasing cost and improving efficiency of LEDs, individuals and companies have increased their usage. The rebound effect is the term used for this.

We are seeing more outdoor lighting, decorative lights, and giant LED billboards than ever before. So, while each light uses less energy, the total amount of illumination (and energy use) has gone up in many places. 

The use of artificial light worldwide, particularly outdoors, has increased by approximately 10% annually. This is due primarily to the adoption of efficient, low-cost LEDs, as significant energy savings have created new environmental challenges.

Are LED Lights Harmful to Human Health?

Beyond environmental issues, some studies have raised concerns about potential health hazards linked to LED lighting. 

The blue light emitted by LEDs can damage the retina, especially in children whose eyes are still developing. This may lead to poor sleep quality and associated health issues. 

Besides, while artificial indoor LED lights generally don't pose a hazard, LED flicker, though often imperceptible, can cause headaches and visual fatigue in sensitive individuals. While LEDs are usually safe, it's wise to use warm-toned bulbs in the evening and limit screen time before bed. 

To minimise these effects, we can take steps such as:

  1. We can keep using dim red lights for night lighting, as red light is less likely to shift circadian rhythms and suppress melatonin.
  2. Avoid bright screens 2-3 hours before bed or use anti-glare filters when using electronic devices.
  3. Using blue light filters on devices or wearing blue-blocking glasses in the evening.
  4. Choose LED light bulbs with warmer colours that feel comfortable for our eyes.

Can LED Bulbs Degrade?

Most LEDs are non-biodegradable. When they die, they become a problem. This is because they contain plastics, metals, and some toxic materials that linger in landfills for years.

It's not all bad news, though. Some companies, such as LEDVANCE, make recyclable LEDs. They design bulbs that can be taken apart and reused. This initiative aims to reduce the use of new plastics and increase recycling rates in LED manufacturing.

Should We Stop Buying LED Lights?

Absolutely not! While LEDs have flaws due to some environmental factors, they are our best bet for eco-friendly lighting right now. Sure, they have some challenges, like the blue light issues and recycling difficulties, but their energy savings are significant.

They use way less power than old bulbs, which means lower carbon emissions.

For your home, LEDs are usually a smart choice. They save energy and money, which is a win-win. Plus, they last almost forever, so we are not constantly replacing our left and right bulbs, unlike traditional incandescent bulbs. 

That means switching to LED lights will reduce energy demand from power plants. Plus, since LED bulbs last much longer, we may need to throw away fewer lights, keeping our landfills a bit cleaner and less waste.

 However, we need to be smart about how we use them by choosing warm tones and not overdoing them with outdoor lighting.

Are LEDs Sustainable?

To truly be sustainable, LED technology needs to evolve. We need to find ways to address the negative impacts while maintaining the energy-saving benefits. This might involve developing new types of LEDs, improving manufacturing processes, or creating better recycling systems.

In the meantime, we consumers make LED lighting more sustainable by turning off lights when not in use. Besides, we need to be aware and look for LED recycling programs in our areas. Moreover, using smart lighting, motion sensors, and timers can reduce unnecessary light use.

Final Thought: The Future of LED Lighting

As new technology emerges, the future of LED technology will cover the current challenges which pave the way for new development. Until then, we will continue to see the environmental impact of LED lights as positive and negative. Though not as ideal as we had thought, they are nonetheless preferable to conventional incandescent bulbs.

Through our purchase decisions, we as consumers have the power to influence the type of future that involves lighting our environment. If we insist on environmentally responsible solutions and use LEDs with caution, we may minimise their drawbacks while still reaping their benefits. All efforts matter when it comes to safeguarding our environment, after all.

So, are LED lights bad for the environment? The answer is neither a yes or a no. However, like any other technology, it comes with its own set of challenges. We must find the correct balance and keep pushing for even better, greener and environmentally friendly lighting options.